Strategic Asset Allocation vs Tactical Asset Allocation

Asset allocation is a crucial element in building a successful investment portfolio. The choice of asset allocation strategy can significantly impact your returns and ability to achieve your financial goals. Among the most popular approaches are strategic asset allocation and tactical asset allocation. Each strategy offers unique advantages and caters to different investor preferences and market conditions.

Understanding the differences between strategic asset allocation and tactical asset allocation is essential for investors looking to optimise their portfolios for both stability and growth.

In this article, we will explore the characteristics, benefits, and key differences of strategic and tactical asset allocation to help you determine which strategy best suits your investment style and objectives.

Simply put, this is a portfolio strategy. In strategic asset allocation, an investor decides to allocate specific targets for different asset classes. Moreover, investors also frequently realign the portfolio as per the initial allocation in case of divergences that occur owing to differing returns over time.

In this strategy, the actual allocations are made based on factors that include the time horizon, risk tolerance of the investor, and objectives of investment. The allocations are also dynamic over time as these parameters change. Compared to tactical asset allocation, strategic asset allocation is conducive to a passive trading, buying and holding strategy. One of the core principles of this allocation style is the emphasis on portfolio diversification across different asset classes to improve returns and reduce risks.

In this comparison of strategic asset allocation and tactical asset allocation, let us now understand some advantages of strategic asset allocation:
 

• Risk management

When your portfolio is diversified, you can limit risk exposure to specific asset classes. A portfolio that is diversified can still perform well when a few assets do not perform well, as profits in the other assets can offset small losses. Over time, this strategy ensures stable returns.
 

• Long-term investment strategy

This strategy is well-suited for long-term investments as you can sail through market volatility. This strategy efficiently balances high, medium, and low-risk investments, which is conducive to capital growth and wealth generation in the long run.
 

• Tax benefits

If you subscribe to this style, you can also benefit from certain benefits in the taxation framework. For instance, if you hold positions for more than a year, the tax on your earnings will be less than the capital gains tax on the short-term earnings.
 

• Flexibility

This strategy is flexible and enables investors to craft portfolios according to their specific requirements, goals, risk appetite, and personal preferences.

• Stable returns

As this strategy advocates for an efficient asset mix, this diversification ensures stable (and even higher) returns in the long run.

In the comparison between strategic asset allocation and tactical asset allocation, this is a type of active portfolio management strategy. In this, the allocation of assets in a portfolio is more dynamic to leverage the market’s strengths. As this is a more active approach, it unlocks a higher ceiling for profits in the short term. However, it is important to note that this strategy is moderately active as the portfolio allocation is reset to the original once the set goals in the short term are achieved.

Along with the meaning of strategic asset allocation and tactical asset allocation, it is also important to know the major advantages of each style. Here are some key advantages of tactical asset allocation:
 

• Adaptability to fluctuations in the market

This kind of asset allocation is a great way for investors to constantly adapt their portfolio to the changes in the market and even profit from the market volatility.
 

• Potential for higher returns

As market trends can be capitalised to make enhanced profits, this strategy has the potential to provide investors with higher returns.
 

• Risk management

This strategy is also beneficial for investors who want to frequently modify their portfolio and assets to adapt to market risks, which can offer protection against potential downturns in the market.
 

• Active management advantage

Managing your portfolio actively can help you secure returns higher than passive strategies when the market is down or highly volatile.

Choosing between strategic asset allocation and tactical asset allocation depends on your individual financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment horizon. Consider the following:

• If you prefer a stable, long-term approach with less frequent portfolio adjustments, strategic asset allocation may be the right choice for you. This strategy focuses on maintaining a diversified portfolio that aligns with your risk tolerance and investment objectives, aiming for steady growth over time.

• If you are willing to actively manage your portfolio and are comfortable with taking on more risk for the potential of higher short-term returns, tactical asset allocation could be more suitable. This approach allows for greater flexibility and the opportunity to adapt to market conditions, potentially offering higher returns during favourable market trends.

The choice between strategic asset allocation and tactical asset allocation should reflect your personal financial situation, goals, and comfort with market risk. In some cases, even a combination of both may provide a balanced approach to achieving your investment objectives.

Conclusion

Deciding between strategic asset allocation and tactical asset allocation involves evaluating your financial goals, preferences, and risk tolerance. Strategic asset allocation is ideal for those seeking a long-term, stable investment strategy that emphasises diversification and passive management. On the other hand, tactical asset allocation offers greater flexibility and the potential for higher short-term returns by actively responding to market changes. It is extremely important to align your portfolio allocation strategy with your personal financial situation and investment objectives, allowing you to build a portfolio that meets your specific goals.

Related Articles

• Why asset allocation is important
• What is scalping?
• What is the straddle strategy
• What is the blue ocean strategy?