Investing in mutual funds in a minor’s name offers a plethora of noticeable advantages, however it is also important to consider several potential drawbacks. Understanding these disadvantages can help you make a more informed decision. A few of these disadvantages are discussed in the paragraphs below:
1. Minor's limited control
While investing in a mutual fund in the name of the minor, they are not directly in control of investments until the child attains the age of majority, which in most cases is 18. During this period, he guardian or parent manages the account and would make all the investment decisions on behalf of the minor. This may be a major disadvantage if the minor wants to be actively involved in the investments or make decisions about them. For example, if they want to change investment strategies or reallocate assets, that will not occur until they take legal control of the account. This delay can be frustrating for minors who wish to engage more actively in managing their financial portfolio.
2. Legal difficulty
It is sometimes legally complex to make a mutual fund account that is under the custody of a guardian passed on to a minor on attaining majority. It involves much paperwork and formality, most of which may be tedious and time-consuming. It may involve identity proofs by the guardians, filling in certain legal forms, and even visiting a lawyer to seek advice in order to smoothly transact the transfer process. Any errors or delays in this process could result in complications or disruptions in the management of the investment account. This unnecessarily puts both the guardian and the minor under stress or delay in access or management of such funds upon attainment of the age of majority.
3. Implications for taxation
While investment in the name of a minor brings along some tax benefits, like perhaps lower taxation rates on income, there are also implications that may impact the overall tax liability. The income that accrues from such investments may get hit by the clubbing provisions under which such income gets added to the guardian's income for tax purposes. In such a situation, this may push the guardian to a higher tax bracket, thereby increasing the overall tax burden. Additionally, the rules and thresholds for income clubbing can vary, making it important for guardians to carefully track and manage tax implications to avoid unexpected liabilities and ensure compliance with tax regulations.
4. Inadequate immediate access
The mutual funds invested in the name of a minor are not available normally till the minor attains majority. This lack of liquidity can be a big disadvantage in case of unexpected needs or emergencies. For instance, it is difficult to withdraw the invested amount on urgent grounds like medical expenses or educational expenses prior to attainment of 18 years of age. It is retained in the investment until it undergoes a legal transition of control, which can hamper the flexibility and financial responsiveness of the guardian or the minor at desperate times.
5. Changes in regulations pose a risk
Investments held in a minor's name are subject to regulatory frameworks that may change over time. Guardians ought to monitor any regulatory updates or modifications that can alter the terms, conditions, or benefits under which the investment is held. Regulatory changes may impact taxes, the investment climate, or even the regulations related to the transmission of account control. Otherwise, failure to keep track of regulatory changes may lead to non-compliance with the regulation or missing rebalancing opportunities. Thus, trustees must keep track of regulatory developments to ensure that their investment strategy remains compliant with existing laws and regulations.
6. Market dangers
Just like all mutual funds, investments made in a minor's name are subject to market risks. This means that their values would fluctuate as per market conditions, and therefore the overall performance and value of the portfolio get affected. In such a case, if the market takes a downturn, it can result in a fall in the value of investments, thereby impacting the financial returns that may be expected when the minor attains adulthood. This exposes one to the market volatility, which brings out the essence of careful mutual fund selection and management to reduce these risks or even minimize the losses that may be incurred during the period of investment.
7. Automatic control transfer
When a minor reaches the legal adult age, the mutual fund account is automatically transferred under his or her control. This can be risky if he or she is financially unaware or inexperienced. Lacking requisite skills, young adults can make poor investment decisions or mismanage the assets. It is, therefore, incumbent upon the guardian to prepare the minor for the transition and ensure that he/she receives adequate financial education and guidance to deal with the investment portfolio responsibly when they reach the age.
8. Limited investment options
Certain mutual funds may not be available for investment in a minor’s name, which can limit the variety of choices for guardians. Some funds may have certain restrictions or eligibility criteria that rule out accounts held by minors. It can pose a risk to the diversification of the investment portfolio and customization in accordance with the financial goals of the guardian about the minor. Hence, guardians may have to work their way through such restrictions and find suitable investment options that best meet their objectives while still being compliant with the respective minor account regulations.
9. Requirements for education
Investing in the name of a minor requires quite good financial knowledge and investment acumen. Guardians need to be financially literate to take appropriate decisions and manage the investments properly. If a guardian is deficient in this aspect of financial literacy, then he will make less-than-optimal investment decisions that might have an impact on the growth and performance of the portfolio. In such need for financial literacy, guardians ought to be well-informed and educated enough about the principles of investments to ensure that they are making decisions that would benefit the future well-being of the minor.