IPO Grading

• IPO grading provides an independent assessment of a company’s fundamental strengths, helping investors gauge the potential and quality of an IPO.
• The grading process involves a thorough analysis of multiple factors, including financial health, management quality, and industry prospects.
• Investors should consider IPO ratings alongside other critical factors, such as market conditions and the company’s disclosures.

The IPO grading process is a unique Indian framework. The need for IPO grading is rooted in the market dynamic of initial public offerings, as they have the potential to be both risky and incredibly rewarding.

Conducted by an agency for providing credit ratings approved by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), the IPO grading process involves intensive and wide-ranging due diligence on IPOs to provide investors with another checkpoint to analyse before investing. There are several milestones in the process, which include assessing the management, customers, and suppliers of the IPO issuing company, its industry positioning, potential or pending lawsuit evaluation, analysis of financial and corporate data, intellectual property, etc.

Simply put, the IPO grading process assigns grades to company IPOs based on a set of comprehensive assessment factors, some of which we will discuss in the next sections. It is conducted on a five-point scale where five reflects the strongest fundamentals. It can be taken up before or after the documents are filed. Company IPOs are graded by a SEBI-approved and registered credit rating agency.

The IPO ratings assigned through IPO grading can be a significantly helpful marker for investors, as they help them understand the potential and the overall quality of an IPO. Think of the IPO rating as an independent and objective opinion that seeks to bridge the information gap between investors and businesses. IPO grading helps investors make informed choices by also giving insights into the potential risk in IPO investments.

The overall objective of IPO grading is to provide insights to investors as credit rating agencies analyse several aspects of the company launching an IPO, including management quality, financial and other business prospects, and the standard corporate governance norms.

Still, as investors, everyone should make an independent decision concerning investments, as the IPO rating is not a recommendation for buying.

Upon the launch of the program, it was mandated that companies secure an IPO rating for their offering in the market. This was true for all companies that decided to go public post-May 1st, 2007. However, since February 4th, 2014, the IPO grading process is not optional for companies that issue IPOs.

In the IPO grading process, the credit rating agency typically conducts an analysis of the fundamentals of the company behind an IPO.

The process of IPO grading in India consists of a thorough analysis of a firm’s management, financial statement, and trends in the sector, among other investments. For this, agencies that provide credit ratings leverage a comprehensive mix of qualitative and quantitative metrics. This includes historical performance, financial ratios, prospects of future growth, etc.

Through this process, grades are provided to them on a five-point scale. The highest rating is 5, while the lowest is 1. A rating of 5 is used to describe robust fundamental metrics, and a rating of 1 indicates the poorest fundamentals. The scale is described below:

• Grade 5 - Strong fundamentals
• Grade 4 - Above-average fundamentals
• Grade 3 - Average fundamentals
• Grade 2 - Below-average fundamentals
• Grade 1 - Poor fundamentals

This system of IPO grading directly augments investors with more knowledge, which can help them analyse whether investing in an IPO is right for them.

At this juncture, it is also important to understand that IPO grading is not a direct recommendation system to subscribe to an IPO and should not be solely relied upon for investments. The best method to utilise IPO ratings is to view them in conjunction with the business’s disclosures, risk factors, share offer price, and other aspects.

With the process and significance of IPO grading explained, let us now shift to understanding some primary aspects that influence these ratings. The process is typically quite comprehensive, and the specific factors considered often vary depending on the company and industry. Some primary factors affecting IPO grading are:

• Competitive positioning and business prospects
  • Company prospects
  • Industry prospects
• Financial positioning
  • Balance sheet
  • Annual reports
  • Operating cash flows
  • Assets and liabilities
• Quality of management
• Policies concerning corporate governance practices
• Risk management
• Profiles of company promoters
• Marketing strategies
• Growth prospects
• Competitive advantage
• Technological interaction and initiative
• Operational efficiency
• New project prospects and risks
• Historical litigation and compliance information

IPO grading can be used by investors to make more informed decisions as the ratings assess numerous aspects of a company, like financial positioning, growth prospects, and competitive advantage, among others. These are significant aspects of fundamental company analysis and influence investing decisions.

Investors can locate IPO grades in the IPO prospectus and advertisements. The specific reasons and the description of the analysis of a certain rating or grade can be found in the grading letter, which is issued by the rating agency to the registered office of the company.

Even though IPO grading provides objective assessments, SEBI recommends that all investors make independent decisions considering a wide variety of factors for investment and not rely solely on IPO ratings.

Even though IPO grading is a robust and comprehensive process, there are a few instances when you as an investor should not rely on it:

• Making recommendations towards a subscription to a specific IPO
• Forecasting the share listing prices
• Identifying malpractice or fraud in a business
• Forming judgements about bidding prices
• Assuming that SEBI is directly behind the IPO rating
   

Conclusion

IPO grading in India provides an objective and systematic evaluation of initial public offerings, offering investors an additional layer of insight into the fundamentals of a company before making investment decisions. While the IPO grading process offers valuable assessments by examining various aspects such as financial health, management quality, and industry positioning, it is crucial for investors to use these ratings as one of many tools in their decision-making arsenal. Ultimately, the most informed investment decisions come from a combination of objective IPO ratings and a thorough personal analysis of all available information.
 

Related Articles

• How to Check your IPO Allotment Status?
• Initial Public Offerings (IPO)
• What is IPO Subscription and What Does It Indicate
• What is IPO Cycle