Eligibility for ESOPs
Every employee, excluding directors and promoters with over 10% equity holdings, is eligible for an Employee Stock Option Plan (ESOP) if they satisfy any of the following criteria:
- Full-time or part-time Director of the Company.
- Current employee of a subsidiary, associate, or holding company, regardless of whether they are based in the UK or overseas.
- Permanent employee working in an Indian or foreign office of the company.
Benefits of ESOPs for employees
Benefit
|
Explanation
|
Stock Ownership
|
Employees gain ownership in the company, aligning their interests with the success of the organization.
|
Dividend Income
|
Employees are entitled to receive dividends, providing them with an additional income stream linked to company profits.
|
Acquire Stock at a Discount
|
Employees may purchase company shares at a discounted price or at the fair market value, offering a financial benefit.
|
Enhancing Productivity
|
Ownership increases commitment and motivation, encouraging employees to be productive and contribute to company success.
|
Benefits of ESOPs for employers
Benefit
|
Explanation
|
Attract and Retain Employees
|
ESOPs help companies attract and retain talent, especially when salaries alone may not be competitive.
|
Reduce Attrition
|
ESOPs can reduce turnover, especially in industries with high attrition rates, by incentivizing long-term employee loyalty.
|
Long-Term Commitment
|
Companies offer shares over time, incentivizing employees to stay with the company and align with long-term goals.
|
ESOP vs. stock options: Key differences
ESOPs grant actual ownership of company shares, often at no upfront cost, fostering long-term loyalty. Stock options, on the other hand, offer the right to buy shares at a set price, benefiting employees when the stock value rises.
Other equity compensation plans
Companies may offer alternative equity plans to reward employees and align them with long-term business goals.
Type of plan
|
What it offers
|
Key features
|
Direct Stock Purchase Plans (DSPPs)
|
Lets employees buy company shares using after-tax income.
|
Often includes a small discount on the stock price; may be part of a tax-qualified plan.
|
Restricted stock
|
Grants employees actual shares, often as part of a reward package.
|
Comes with conditions like vesting schedules or performance targets before full ownership.
|
Stock options
|
Gives employees the right to buy company stock at a fixed price in the future.
|
Profitable if the stock price rises above the set purchase price during the option period.
|
Phantom stock
|
Mimics actual stock ownership without issuing real shares.
|
Provides cash bonuses based on the value of the company’s stock.
|
Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)
|
Rewards employees for stock value growth without requiring them to buy shares.
|
Employees receive cash or shares based on the increase in stock price over a set period.
|
Which model is right for your company?
The best employee ownership model for your company depends on various factors, including your financial situation, company culture, and long-term goals. It's essential to consider the tax implications, administrative costs, and potential dilution of ownership when choosing a model.
ESOP taxation and legal considerations
Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) have a dual tax impact:
- Exercise of ESOPs: When an employee exercises their option to purchase company shares, the difference between the Fair Market Value (FMV) of the shares on the date of exercise and the exercise price is considered a taxable perquisite. This perquisite is taxed at the employee's marginal income tax rate. However, the government has relaxed these rules for start-ups, allowing employees to defer the tax on the perquisite until the earlier of five years from the grant date or the date of sale.
- Sale of ESOP Shares: When an employee sells their ESOP shares, the capital gain or loss is calculated based on the difference between the selling price and the FMV on the date of exercise.
- Short-Term Capital Gains Tax: If the shares are sold within one year of purchase, the profit is taxed as short-term capital gains at a flat rate of 15%.
- Long-Term Capital Gains Tax: If the shares are held for more than one year, the profit is taxed as long-term capital gains. The current long-term capital gains tax rate for equity shares is 10% on gains exceeding Rs. 1 lakh.
Taxation of Foreign ESOPs in India
If an Indian resident receives ESOP benefits from a foreign company, the perquisite value is taxable in India. The tax implications would be similar to those of domestic ESOPs.
It's important to consult with a tax professional to understand the specific tax implications of your ESOPs, as tax laws can be complex and subject to change.
Tax implications when selling ESOP shares
When employees sell their ESOP shares, they are subject to capital gains tax based on the holding period. If shares are sold within 12 months, short-term capital gains tax applies, while sales after 12 months attract long-term capital gains tax. Additionally, ESOPs are taxed as perquisites at the time of exercise. Below is a table summarizing the tax treatment:
Tax component
|
Condition
|
Tax rate
|
Perquisite Tax
|
At the time of exercise
|
As per income tax slab
|
Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG)
|
Sold within 12 months
|
15%
|
Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG)
|
Sold after 12 months
|
10% (if gains exceed Rs.1 lakh)
|
What happens to ESOPs when a company gets listed?
When a company gets listed on a stock exchange, the dynamics of its ESOP program may undergo changes. There are a few potential scenarios:
- Company buyback
The company may choose to buy back its shares from employees who hold ESOPs. This often provides employees with a straightforward method to realise the value of their ESOP holdings.
- Employee Sales
Employees may decide to sell their ESOP shares on stock exchanges once the company is publicly traded. This allows employees to take advantage of market liquidity and potentially realise gains based on the prevailing stock price.
How to value ESOPs
ESOP valuation can be conducted using two primary approaches:
- Intrinsic value method: This method focuses on the immediate, inherent value of the option. It calculates the difference between the current market price of the company's stock and the exercise price of the option. If the market price exceeds the exercise price, the option has intrinsic value. However, this method doesn't consider factors like the time to expiration or the volatility of the stock price, which can significantly impact the option's true value.
- Fair value method: This method provides a more accurate valuation by considering various factors that influence the option's value, such as:
- Current market price of the company's stock: This is a key input, as it directly influences the option's potential profit.
- Exercise price: The price at which the employee can purchase the stock.
- Time to expiration: The period during which the employee can exercise the option.
- Volatility of the stock price: The degree to which the company's stock price fluctuates.
- Risk-free interest rate: The rate of return on a risk-free investment, which is used to discount future cash flows.
- Expected dividends: The anticipated dividends the company may pay during the option's life.
Pros and cons of Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs)
Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) offer employees the opportunity to acquire company shares—often at a discount or as part of their compensation. This ownership can enhance motivation, engagement, and alignment with business goals. Employees may feel a stronger sense of pride and responsibility, contributing more actively to the company’s success. Financially, ESOPs can help build long-term wealth through dividends and capital appreciation.
However, there are challenges. ESOPs can lead to a lack of portfolio diversification, tying both employment and retirement savings to the company’s performance. Newer employees may receive fewer benefits and hold limited influence, while growing participation can dilute ownership and voting power for long-term employees.Top of Form
What happens to ESOPs when a company gets listed?
In the hypothetical scenario in the Indian market, let's consider a software company called "TechSolutions Pvt. Ltd." that decides to implement an ESOP for its employees.
TechSolutions Pvt. Ltd. has been performing exceptionally well in the market, and the management believes that providing ownership opportunities to its employees will further motivate them and align their interests with the company's growth.
Here's how the ESOP might work for TechSolutions Pvt. Ltd.:
- Offer details: The company announces an ESOP scheme, offering eligible employees the opportunity to purchase company shares at a discounted price. For example, employees may have the option to purchase shares at 20% below the market price.
- Eligibility criteria: The ESOP scheme may be open to all full-time employees who have completed a certain period of service, such as one year with the company.
- Vesting period: The company may implement a vesting period during which employees gradually gain ownership rights to the shares. For instance, shares could vest over a period of three years, with one-third of the shares becoming fully owned by the employee each year.
- Exercise period: Employees are typically given a window of time, known as the exercise period, during which they can purchase the vested shares. This period could be, for example, six months from the date of vesting.
- Payment options: Employees may have the option to purchase shares either through a cash payment or by opting for an ESOP loan provided by the company.
- Tax implications: The company would provide information on the tax implications of participating in the ESOP scheme, including any tax obligations upon exercising the options or selling the shares.
- Benefits: By participating in the ESOP, employees have the opportunity to become shareholders in the company, potentially benefiting from any increase in the company's stock price over time. This can serve as a valuable incentive for employee retention and motivation.
In this example, TechSolutions Pvt. Ltd. effectively implements an ESOP scheme to empower its employees with ownership in the company, fostering a sense of loyalty, alignment, and motivation among its workforce.
How Bajaj Finance Limited can help with ESOP liquidity?
For employees seeking financial support to maximise their ESOP investments, financial institutions, and lenders like Bajaj Finance Limited offer ESOP financing options at competitive rates. These financial products are designed to assist employees in managing the financial aspects of exercising their ESOPs and realising the potential gains. If you are eager to capitalise on ESOPs but have financial concerns, get in touch with us today to explore the available financial aid for your ESOP investments.
Conclusion
Employee stock ownership plans (ESOPs) are not just a corporate buzzword; they are a dynamic way for companies to engage, motivate, and retain their workforce. By offering ownership stakes to employees, ESOPs promote a sense of shared success and financial security. Employees benefit from ownership, dividend income, discounted stock acquisition, job satisfaction, and enhanced productivity. However, it is essential for employees to grasp the associated tax implications, as they can significantly impact the financial outcomes of their ESOP participation.