Fixed Deposit vs Other Savings Options Which is Better
In summary
VPF and PPF are long-term savings options that differ in eligibility, contribution limits, interest rates, withdrawal rules and tax treatment. VPF is available to eligible employees who want to contribute more to their existing Employees' Provident Fund (EPF) account. PPF is a government-backed savings scheme that eligible resident individuals can open independently.
- VPF: Allows eligible employees to make voluntary contributions over and above their regular EPF contribution. It earns the applicable EPF interest rate.
- PPF: Allows annual deposits between Rs.500 and Rs.1.5 lakh, with an initial tenure of 15 years.
- Interest rates: VPF earns the rate applicable to EPF for the relevant financial year, while PPF earns the government-notified rate, which may be revised quarterly.
- Withdrawals: VPF follows EPF withdrawal provisions, while PPF permits partial withdrawals and premature closure only under specified conditions.
- Tax benefits: Eligible contributions may qualify for deductions under the applicable tax provisions, subject to limits. Interest taxation and withdrawal exemptions depend on the relevant rules.
The choice between VPF and PPF depends on your employment status, retirement goals, savings capacity, liquidity requirements and tax situation.
What is Voluntary Provident Fund (VPF)?
-
Voluntary Provident Fund (VPF) is an additional contribution made by an employee towards their existing Employees' Provident Fund (EPF) account. It allows eligible employees to save more for retirement by contributing a higher portion of their salary towards provident fund savings.
Under the standard EPF structure, an employee generally contributes 12% of eligible wages towards EPF. Through VPF, an employee can voluntarily increase their contribution, subject to applicable EPF rules and payroll arrangements.
The additional VPF contribution is credited to the employee's provident fund account and earns interest at the applicable EPF rate. However, the employer is not required to make a matching contribution on the voluntary amount.
VPF may suit salaried individuals who want to increase their retirement savings through salary deductions instead of managing another investment account.
What is Public Provident Fund (PPF)?
Public Provident Fund (PPF) is a government-backed long-term savings scheme designed to encourage individuals to save for retirement and other future financial goals. It is not linked to employment, so eligible individuals can open and manage an account independently.
A PPF account can be opened through authorised banks and post offices. Account holders can deposit a minimum of Rs.500 and a maximum of Rs.1.5 lakh per financial year.
PPF has an initial tenure of 15 years, calculated from the end of the financial year in which the account is opened. After maturity, the account holder may withdraw the accumulated amount or extend the account in blocks of five years, subject to the applicable rules.
The scheme also provides limited loan and partial withdrawal facilities during the tenure.
What is the difference between VPF and PPF?
-
VPF and PPF differ in how they operate, who can contribute, how much can be invested and when the money can be accessed.
Comparison parameter VPF PPF Full form Voluntary Provident Fund Public Provident Fund Nature Additional voluntary contribution to EPF Government-backed individual savings scheme Eligibility Eligible EPF members Eligible resident individuals Linked to employment Yes No Contribution Additional contribution through salary, subject to EPF rules and payroll arrangements Rs.500 to Rs.1.5 lakh per financial year Employer contribution No additional matching contribution on the VPF portion No employer contribution Interest rate Same as applicable EPF interest rate Government-notified rate, reviewed periodically Interest calculation Under EPF interest-crediting rules Calculated under PPF scheme rules and credited annually Tenure No separate fixed tenure; remains within EPF framework 15 years initially Extension No separate five-year extension facility Extendable in five-year blocks Withdrawal Subject to EPF withdrawal rules Partial withdrawal and premature closure subject to scheme conditions Tax deduction Eligible contribution may qualify under applicable tax provisions, subject to overall limits Eligible contribution may qualify under applicable tax provisions, subject to overall limits Interest taxation Excess employee contributions may result in taxable interest Interest generally exempt under applicable rules Account type Part of the EPF account Separate PPF account Both options can help build long-term savings, but VPF is associated with employment and EPF membership, whereas PPF offers independent savings for eligible individuals.
What are the interest rates for VPF and PPF?
VPF does not have an independent interest rate. It earns the interest rate applicable to EPF for the relevant financial year. PPF interest is notified by the Government of India and may change every quarter.
| Scheme | Interest rate | Rate period |
|---|---|---|
| EPF/VPF | 8.25% p.a. | FY 2025–26 |
| PPF | 7.1% p.a. | October–December 2026 |
The EPF rate of 8.25% shown above relates to FY 2025–26. The EPF rate for a subsequent financial year should be checked separately once officially declared and approved.
The PPF rate of 7.1% is applicable for the October–December 2026 quarter. Since the government reviews PPF interest rates periodically, the rate may change during the 15-year tenure.
Interest rates alone should not determine your choice. Contribution flexibility, withdrawal rules, tax treatment and the time for which you can keep the money invested are also important.
What are the tax benefits of VPF and PPF?
-
VPF and PPF may offer tax benefits, but the deductions and exemptions depend on the applicable income-tax provisions, tax regime, contribution amount and other conditions.
VPF tax benefits
VPF contributions are treated as employee contributions to a recognised provident fund, subject to applicable rules.
The key tax considerations include:
- Contribution deduction: Eligible EPF and VPF employee contributions may qualify for a deduction under the applicable tax provisions, subject to the overall eligible savings limit.
- Interest taxation: Interest earned on employee provident fund contributions exceeding the prescribed annual threshold may be taxable. The threshold is generally Rs.2.5 lakh where employer contributions are made, and Rs.5 lakh in specified cases where there is no employer contribution.
- Withdrawal taxation: Qualifying EPF withdrawals may be exempt from tax, subject to applicable service-period and other conditions. Premature withdrawals may have tax implications.
A higher VPF contribution does not automatically result in an additional tax deduction beyond the applicable overall limit.
PPF tax benefits
PPF generally offers favourable tax treatment at the contribution, interest and maturity stages.
- Contribution: Eligible PPF contributions may qualify for a deduction under the applicable tax provisions, subject to the overall limit and tax regime.
- Interest: Interest earned on an eligible PPF account is generally exempt from income tax.
- Maturity proceeds: Eligible PPF maturity proceeds are generally exempt from tax under applicable rules.
The availability of contribution deductions depends on the tax regime and applicable law. Individuals opting for a tax regime that does not allow specified savings deductions cannot claim those deductions merely because they contribute to PPF.
What are the withdrawal rules for VPF and PPF?
-
VPF and PPF have different withdrawal frameworks. VPF follows EPF provisions, while PPF withdrawals are governed by the Public Provident Fund Scheme.
VPF withdrawal rules
Since VPF contributions form part of the EPF account, the withdrawal conditions applicable to EPF generally apply to VPF balances as well.
Eligible members may access funds for specified purposes, such as:
- Medical treatment under applicable provisions
- Housing-related requirements, including purchase or construction, subject to conditions
- Education or marriage-related expenses, subject to eligibility
- Retirement or final settlement
- Other permitted circumstances under EPF rules
Partial withdrawals, advances and final settlement depend on the reason for withdrawal, membership details, service conditions and applicable EPF provisions.
VPF does not have a separate universal five-year withdrawal rule. The applicable EPF withdrawal provisions must be checked before applying for a claim.
PPF withdrawal rules
PPF has a 15-year initial tenure, but it offers limited access to funds before maturity.
- Partial withdrawals are generally permitted from the seventh financial year, subject to the prescribed balance-based limit.
- Partial withdrawals are generally restricted to one per financial year.
- Premature closure is permitted only in specified circumstances and after the prescribed period.
- At maturity, the account holder can withdraw the balance or choose to extend the account under applicable rules.
PPF withdrawals are subject to account-age conditions, eligible balances and scheme-specific limits. It is therefore important to consider liquidity needs before opening the account.
What are the eligibility criteria for VPF and PPF?
VPF and PPF are available to different categories of individuals.
| Eligibility parameter | VPF | PPF |
|---|---|---|
| Eligible investor | Employee who is an EPF member | Eligible resident individual |
| Employment requirement | Yes | No |
| Self-employed individuals | Not eligible to contribute through VPF | May open a PPF account |
| Students | Not eligible unless covered as an EPF member | May open an account subject to eligibility rules |
| Retired individuals | Generally not available as a new VPF contribution facility outside EPF membership | May maintain an eligible PPF account, subject to scheme rules |
| Minor account | Not applicable as an independent VPF account | Guardian may open an account on behalf of a minor |
| NRI | Governed by EPF membership rules and status | NRIs cannot open a new PPF account |
VPF is suitable only for individuals who have access to the EPF framework and can make additional contributions through their employer's payroll system. PPF is independent of employment and can be used by eligible individuals to build long-term savings.
VPF vs PPF: Which is better?
Neither VPF nor PPF is universally better. The suitable option depends on your savings goals, contribution capacity, employment status and the time for which you can keep your money invested.
When may VPF be suitable?
VPF may be worth considering if you:
- Are an eligible EPF member and want to increase your retirement savings
- Prefer automatic salary deductions for disciplined saving
- Want to make additional contributions within the EPF framework
- Have a long-term savings horizon
- Can manage the liquidity restrictions associated with provident fund savings
Since VPF contributions are not matched by your employer, the additional savings come entirely from your own contribution.
When may PPF be suitable?
PPF may be worth considering if you:
- Want to build savings independently of your employment
- Are looking for a long-term savings option with a 15-year initial tenure
- Prefer to make deposits according to your cash flow within the annual limits
- Want to save for long-term goals such as retirement or a future financial requirement
- Prefer a government-backed savings scheme with favourable tax treatment
PPF offers contribution flexibility within its prescribed limits. However, its long tenure and restricted withdrawals may not suit people who need frequent access to their savings.
Can you invest in both VPF and PPF?
Yes, eligible individuals can contribute to VPF and maintain a PPF account simultaneously. The two schemes serve different purposes and can be used together to build long-term savings.
For example, a salaried employee may increase their EPF contributions through VPF to strengthen retirement savings while making separate PPF deposits for another long-term financial goal.
However, tax deductions on eligible contributions are subject to the applicable aggregate limit and tax regime. Contributions across eligible savings instruments do not automatically create separate deduction limits.
VPF and PPF are long-term savings options that can help individuals build financial security, but they operate differently. VPF allows eligible EPF members to increase their retirement contributions through salary deductions, while PPF provides an independent savings facility with a 15-year initial tenure.
VPF may suit salaried employees who want to accumulate additional retirement savings within the EPF framework. PPF may suit eligible individuals looking for a government-backed savings option with flexible annual contributions within the prescribed limits.
Before choosing between the two, compare the applicable interest rates, contribution limits, withdrawal restrictions and tax implications. The decision should reflect your employment status, financial goals and liquidity requirements.
Check out different FD Rates
Fixed Deposit variants
Get ROI up to
8.15% p.a.
Senior citizen
Starting with just Rs. 15,000
Get ROI up to
7.75% p.a.
Age below 60 years
Starting with just Rs. 15,000
Get ROI up to
7.75% p.a.
Minor
Starting with just Rs. 15,000
Get ROI up to
7.75% p.a.
HUF
Starting with just Rs. 15,000
Get ROI up to
7.75% p.a.
Sole proprietor
Starting with just Rs. 15,000
Related Articles
Frequently Asked Questions
Overview
Is VPF better than PPF?
VPF may suit salaried EPF members who want to increase their retirement savings through additional salary contributions. PPF may be more suitable for individuals seeking an independent long-term savings account with a 15-year tenure. Neither is universally better. The choice depends on eligibility, contribution capacity, withdrawal needs and tax treatment.
Can I invest in both VPF and PPF?
Yes, eligible EPF members can contribute to VPF and also maintain a PPF account. VPF is an additional contribution within the EPF account, while PPF is an independent savings scheme. However, eligible tax deductions across savings contributions remain subject to the applicable aggregate limits and tax regime.
Is VPF tax-free?
VPF does not have unconditional tax-free treatment. Eligible contributions may qualify for deductions subject to applicable limits. Interest earned on employee contributions exceeding the prescribed annual threshold may be taxable. Qualifying withdrawals may be exempt, depending on service period and other conditions.
Is PPF interest tax-free?
Interest earned on an eligible PPF account is generally exempt from income tax under applicable provisions. Eligible maturity proceeds also generally receive tax-exempt treatment. However, contribution deductions depend on the applicable tax regime and tax rules.
What is the maximum contribution to VPF?
VPF does not have the same fixed annual deposit ceiling as PPF. Employees can make additional voluntary contributions through the EPF framework, subject to applicable rules and payroll arrangements. The permissible contribution amount and implementation process should be confirmed with the employer.
What is the maximum contribution to PPF?
The maximum contribution to PPF is Rs.1.5 lakh per financial year. The minimum annual deposit is Rs.500. Deposits can be made in a lump sum or instalments, subject to scheme rules. Contributions beyond the prescribed limit do not qualify for additional PPF benefits.
Can I withdraw VPF before retirement?
Yes, withdrawals may be permitted under applicable EPF rules for specified purposes or circumstances. The conditions depend on the type of claim, service period, eligibility and other requirements. VPF does not have an independent withdrawal framework separate from EPF.
Can I withdraw PPF before 15 years?
PPF allows partial withdrawals after the prescribed waiting period, generally from the seventh financial year, subject to the scheme's balance-based limits. Premature closure is permitted only in specified circumstances under the scheme rules. The full balance cannot be withdrawn freely at any time.
Which has a higher interest rate, VPF or PPF?
The rates depend on the applicable financial year and quarter. VPF earns the interest rate applicable to EPF, while PPF earns the government-notified small-savings rate. The rates can change, so compare the current officially declared rates rather than assuming one will remain higher throughout the investment period.
Is VPF mandatory?
No. VPF is a voluntary contribution made over and above the employee's regular EPF contribution. Eligible employees can choose whether to contribute more towards provident fund savings, subject to the employer's payroll process and applicable EPF provisions.
Does PPF have a fixed maturity period?
PPF has an initial maturity period of 15 years, calculated from the end of the financial year in which the account is opened. After maturity, the account holder may withdraw the accumulated amount or extend the account in five-year blocks, subject to scheme rules.
Disclaimer
1. Bajaj Finance Limited (“BFL”) is a Non-Banking Finance Company (BAJAJ FINANCE) and Prepaid Payment Instrument Issuer offering financial services viz., loans, deposits, Bajaj Pay Wallet, Bajaj Pay UPI, bill payments and third-party wealth management products. The details mentioned in the respective product/ service document shall prevail in case of any inconsistency with respect to the information referring to BFL products and services on this page.
2. All other information, such as, the images, facts, statistics etc. (“information”) that are in addition to the details mentioned in the BFL’s product/ service document and which are being displayed on this page only depicts the summary of the information sourced from the public domain. The said information is neither owned by BFL nor it is to the exclusive knowledge of BFL. There may be inadvertent inaccuracies or typographical errors or delays in updating the said information. Hence, users are advised to independently exercise diligence by verifying complete information, including by consulting experts, if any. Users shall be the sole owner of the decision taken, if any, about suitability of the same.