Stock SIP vs. Mutual Fund SIP

Stock SIP invests fixed amounts directly into individual stocks periodically, building a portfolio. Mutual Fund SIP invests in a diversified portfolio managed by professionals.
EXPLORE FUNDS
Difference between mutual fund SIP and stock SIP
EXPLORE FUNDS
3 min
16-August-2024

Choosing between Stock SIP and mutual fund SIP depends on individual preferences, risk tolerance, and knowledge. Stock SIP offers the potential for higher returns alongside higher risks, whereas mutual fund SIPs offer diversification and professional management.

Many investors ask: If we can execute a systematic investment plan (SIP) in equity mutual funds, can we not do the same in stocks? The response is that stock SIPs are possible.

SIPs are all about rupee cost averaging. You receive capital appreciation when the stock price rises, and you receive additional shares for the same investment when the price drops. This reasoning holds for both mutual funds and stock SIPs. Stock SIP and Mutual Fund SIP both help individuals invest in stocks and mutual funds regularly and systematically.

Key takeaways

  • Stock SIP means investing a fixed amount regularly into individual stocks to build a stock portfolio over time
  • Mutual Fund SIP is when you regularly invest a fixed amount in a mutual fund. It helps diversify your investments across different industries, reducing risks.
  • Mutual Fund SIPs are less risky than Stock SIPs. Returns may be lower in Mutual Fund SIPs, and you need to stay invested for a set time. Choose based on your goals and tolerance for risk.

What is stock SIP?

Stock SIP means investing a fixed amount regularly into individual stocks to build a stock portfolio over time. Mutual Fund SIP lets investors invest in a diversified portfolio managed by professionals.

Stock SIP offers higher potential returns but also higher risk due to stock market volatility. Mutual Fund SIP provides diversification and professional management.

Investors can benefit from cost averaging with Stock SIP by buying more shares when prices are low and fewer when prices are high. However, the risks involved in stock market fluctuations should be considered.

What is mutual fund SIP?

Mutual Fund SIP is when you regularly invest a fixed amount in a mutual fund. This helps diversify your investments across different industries, reducing risks. It's like spreading your money in different baskets. Your return isn't tied to just one stock or industry, which is good. Investing in a Mutual Fund SIP lets you buy more mutual fund units when prices are low and less when prices are high, which is smart. Professional fund managers handle your money, making sure it grows safely. If the market goes down, your mutual fund investment will also be affected, but not as much as individual stocks.

Key differences between stock SIP and mutual fund SIP

Stock SIP and Mutual Fund SIP are both popular ways to invest money in the stock market with some key distinctions:

  • Stock SIP involves investing a fixed amount directly into individual stocks regularly. Mutual Fund SIP, on the other hand, involves investing in a range of securities managed by professionals.
  • Stock SIP focuses on specific stocks, offering higher potential returns but also higher risks due to market changes. Mutual Fund SIP, on the other hand, offers diversification, spreading risks by investing in various sectors.
  • Stock SIP requires selecting and monitoring individual stocks, needing research skills. Mutual Fund SIP does not require this as professional managers make investment choices.
  • Stock SIP is best for those with a high-risk tolerance and stock market knowledge. Mutual Fund SIP is suitable for those wanting diversification, professional management, and a consistent investment strategy.

Factors to consider before choosing stock SIP

Before choosing SIP in stocks, remember that it can be risky. Individual stocks are more risky than mutual funds. Many things can affect stock prices, like market conditions and company performance.

Also, SIP in stocks requires a lot of research. You need to understand company basics, financial info, and market trends. If you're not an expert, you might struggle to make good choices.

Lastly, investing in stock SIPs needs constant monitoring. You have to keep up with market news and updates on the company. This can take up a lot of time and can be stressful for those who prefer a more hands-off approach.

Why is SIP in mutual funds a good idea?

SIP in mutual funds is a smart idea for a few reasons. First, it helps you save and invest regularly. This builds a good habit of saving money. Additionally, SIPs let you average the cost of your investments. By putting in a fixed amount regularly, you buy more when prices are low and less when prices are high. This helps reduce the impact of market ups and downs on your investments.

Moreover, mutual funds offer diversification. Investing in a mutual fund gives you a mix of different types of investments. This spreads out the risk and lessens the impact of a bad investment.

Lastly, mutual funds are managed by experts. They choose the investments for you, so you don't have to do the research. This makes investing easier for those who don't have the time or knowledge.

Are you searching for the best mutual funds? Check out these different mutual fund categories for smart investing!

Why sip in stocks might not be the best choice

Investing through a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) in individual stocks can be a risky endeavor compared to other investment options like mutual funds. Stocks are highly sensitive to various factors, including economic shifts, company performance, and overall market conditions, which can lead to significant price fluctuations. This inherent volatility makes stock SIPs potentially less stable and more unpredictable.

Selecting stocks for an SIP requires in-depth research and analysis, such as understanding a company’s fundamental principles, reviewing financial statements, and keeping up with market trends and sector dynamics. For investors without the necessary expertise or time, this level of scrutiny can increase the likelihood of making poor investment decisions.

Moreover, managing a stock SIP demands continuous monitoring and regular adjustments based on market changes, financial news, and company-specific updates. This ongoing requirement can be burdensome and time-consuming for those who prefer a more passive investment approach, making stock SIPs less appealing for such investors.

Tax implications for stocks and mutual funds SIP

The tax implications for stocks and mutual funds SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) in India are as follows:

Stocks SIP

  • Tax on dividends: Dividends received from stocks are taxed in the hands of the investor at their applicable income tax slab rate.
  • Tax on capital gains: Short-term capital gains (STCG) from stocks are taxed at the investor's income tax slab rate. Long-term capital gains (LTCG) are taxed at 10% without indexation and 20% with indexation benefits if the gains exceed Rs. 1 lakh.
  • Securities transaction tax (STT): STT is charged at 0.001% of the transaction value when buying or selling stocks.

Mutual funds SIP

  • Tax on dividends: Dividends received from mutual funds are taxed in the hands of the investor at their applicable income tax slab rate.
  • Tax on capital gains: Short-term capital gains (STCG) from mutual funds are taxed at the investor's income tax slab rate. Long-term capital gains (LTCG) are taxed at 10% without indexation and 20% with indexation benefits if the gains exceed Rs. 1 lakh.
  • Securities transaction tax (STT): STT is charged at 0.001% of the transaction value when buying or selling equity funds or hybrid equity-oriented funds. There is no STT on debt funds.

Which is better between Stock SIP or mutual funds SIP?

The choice between a Stock SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) and a Mutual Fund SIP depends on several factors, including the investor's risk tolerance, market expertise, and financial goals. Stock SIPs involve direct investment in a specific stock, providing exposure to market fluctuations and potential higher returns, but are more risky due to the concentration of investments in a single stock. On the other hand, Mutual Fund SIPs invest in a diversified portfolio of assets, reducing the risk associated with individual stocks and providing a more stable return.

While Stock SIPs offer higher returns if the chosen stock performs well, they also mean that losses can be significant if the stock performs poorly. Mutual Fund SIPs, on the other hand, are less risky due to diversification and professional management, but typically offer lower returns. The choice between the two ultimately depends on the investor's individual circumstances, risk tolerance, and financial goals, with Stock SIPs being suitable for investors with higher risk tolerance and market expertise, and Mutual Fund SIPs being better for those who prefer a more passive approach and want to diversify their portfolio with professional management.

Conclusion

In conclusion, investing in Stock SIPs has higher potential returns but also higher risk. Mutual Fund SIPs offer diversification and lower risk through professional management. Mutual Fund SIPs are less risky than Stock SIPs. Returns may be lower in Mutual Fund SIPs, and you need to stay invested for a set time. Choose based on your goals and tolerance for risk.

The Bajaj Mutual Fund Platform features multiple tools, from an online lumpsum calculator to a SIP calculator, intending to make mutual fund investment planning easier. The Bajaj Finserv Mutual Funds Platform, with over 1,000 mutual funds to choose from, can be the ideal place to begin your investment journey.

Essential tools for all mutual fund investors

Mutual Fund Calculator

Lumpsum Calculator

Systematic Investment Plan Calculator

Step Up SIP Calculator

SBI SIP Calculator

HDFC SIP Calculator

Nippon India SIP Calculator

ABSL SIP Calculator

Tata SIP Calculator

BOI SIP Calculator

Motilal Oswal Mutual Fund SIP Calculator

Kotak Bank SIP Calculator

LIC SIP Calculator

Groww SIP Calculator

ITI SIP Calculator

ICICI SIP Calculator

Frequently asked questions

What is the meaning of frequency in stock SIP?
Frequency refers to how often you contribute to your stock SIP. It could be monthly, quarterly, or any other interval that suits your investment strategy and financial goals.
What are the disadvantages of a stock SIP?
Some drawbacks include the lack of guidance compared to mutual funds, which typically have professional fund managers making investment decisions. Stock SIPs also require active management and research, which could be challenging for beginners.
Is it good to invest in stock SIP?
Whether it's a good idea depends on your investment objectives, risk tolerance, and knowledge of the stock market. Stock SIPs can offer the potential for higher returns compared to mutual funds but also involve higher risk and require more active management.
Is it better to invest in stocks or mutual funds?
Both stocks and mutual funds have their pros and cons. Investing directly in stocks can offer higher potential returns but also involves higher risk and requires more time and expertise. Mutual funds provide diversification and professional management but may have lower returns and higher fees.
How do I start a stock SIP?
To start a stock SIP, you typically need to open a trading account with a brokerage firm that offers SIP services. Then, you select the stocks you want to invest in and set up a SIP plan where a fixed amount is deducted from your bank account at regular intervals to buy those stocks.
How do I choose between a Mutual Fund SIP and a Stock SIP?

Choosing between a Mutual Fund SIP and a Stock SIP depends on your risk tolerance, investment knowledge, and the amount of time you can commit. Mutual Fund SIPs are ideal for those who prefer a hands-off approach and value diversification, making them suitable for passive investors. In contrast, Stock SIPs may be more appealing to those with a higher risk tolerance and a strong interest in selecting individual stocks.

What should be the return expectations from a Mutual Fund SIP and Stock SIP?

Return expectations vary based on market conditions and asset performance. Mutual Fund SIPs generally provide more stable returns due to their diversified nature, which helps mitigate risk. Stock SIPs, on the other hand, have the potential for higher returns but come with greater volatility and risk, as they are influenced by the performance of individual stocks.

Is it possible to automate investments in a Stock SIP?

Yes, automating investments in a Stock SIP is possible with some brokerage firms that offer automated SIP facilities for stocks. However, even with automation, it's important to regularly review and adjust your investments to ensure they remain aligned with your financial objectives and market conditions.

Why is diversification important in a SIP?

Diversification is crucial in a SIP because it spreads investment risk across different assets. By investing in a variety of assets, you reduce the impact of any single investment's poor performance on your overall portfolio, leading to more balanced and potentially less volatile returns.

Can I start both Mutual Fund SIP and Stock SIP simultaneously?

Yes, you can invest in both Mutual Fund SIPs and Stock SIPs simultaneously. This approach allows you to balance your portfolio according to your risk tolerance and investment goals, combining the stability of mutual funds with the potential high returns of individual stocks.

How often should I review my SIP investments?

It is advisable to review your SIP investments at least once a quarter. Regular reviews help ensure that your investments continue to align with your financial goals and adapt to any changes in market conditions.

Show More Show Less

Related videos

Bajaj Finserv app for all your financial needs and goals

Trusted by 50 million+ customers in India, Bajaj Finserv App is a one-stop solution for all your financial needs and goals.

You can use the Bajaj Finserv App to:

  • Apply for loans online, such as Instant Personal Loan, Home Loan, Business Loan, Gold Loan, and more.
  • Explore and apply for co-branded credit cards online.
  • Invest in fixed deposits and mutual funds on the app.
  • Choose from multiple insurance for your health, motor and even pocket insurance, from various insurance providers.
  • Pay and manage your bills and recharges using the BBPS platform. Use Bajaj Pay and Bajaj Wallet for quick and simple money transfers and transactions.
  • Apply for Insta EMI Card and get a pre-approved limit on the app. Explore over 1 million products on the app that can be purchased from a partner store on Easy EMIs.
  • Shop from over 100+ brand partners that offer a diverse range of products and services.
  • Use specialised tools like EMI calculators, SIP Calculators
  • Check your credit score, download loan statements, and even get quick customer support—all on the app.

Download the Bajaj Finserv App today and experience the convenience of managing your finances on one app.

Do more with the Bajaj Finserv App!

UPI, Wallet, Loans, Investments, Cards, Shopping and more

GET THE APP

Disclaimer

Bajaj Finance Limited (“BFL”) is an NBFC offering loans, deposits and third-party wealth management products.

The information contained in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute any financial advice. The content herein has been prepared by BFL on the basis of publicly available information, internal sources and other third-party sources believed to be reliable. However, BFL cannot guarantee the accuracy of such information, assure its completeness, or warrant such information will not be changed. 

This information should not be relied upon as the sole basis for any investment decisions. Hence, User is advised to independently exercise diligence by verifying complete information, including by consulting independent financial experts, if any, and the investor shall be the sole owner of the decision taken, if any, about suitability of the same.

Disclaimer:

Bajaj Finance Limited ("BFL") is registered with the Association of Mutual Funds in India ("AMFI") as a distributor of third party Mutual Funds (shortly referred as 'Mutual Funds) with ARN No. 90319

BFL does NOT:

(i) provide investment advisory services in any manner or form:

(ii) carry customized/personalized suitability assessment:

(iii) carry independent research or analysis, including on any Mutual Fund schemes or other investments; and provide any guarantee of return on investment.

In addition to displaying the Mutual fund products of Asset Management Companies, some general information is sourced from third parties, is also displayed on As-is basis, which should NOT be construed as any solicitation or attempt to effect transactions in securities or the rendering any investment advice. Mutual Funds are subject to market risks, including loss of principal amount and Investor should read all Scheme/Offer related documents carefully. The NAV of units issued under the Schemes of mutual funds can go up or down depending on the factors and forces affecting capital markets and may also be affected by changes in the general level of interest rates. The NAV of the units issued under the scheme may be affected, inter-alia by changes in the interest rates, trading volumes, settlement periods, transfer procedures and performance of individual securities forming part of the Mutual Fund. The NAV will inter-alia be exposed to Price/Interest Rate Risk and Credit Risk. Past performance of any scheme of the Mutual fund do not indicate the future performance of the Schemes of the Mutual Fund. BFL shall not be responsible or liable for any loss or shortfall incurred by the investors. There may be other/better alternatives to the investment avenues displayed by BFL. Hence, the final investment decision shall at all times exclusively remain with the investor alone and BFL shall not be liable or responsible for any consequences thereof.

Investment by a person residing outside the territorial jurisdiction of India is not acceptable nor permitted.

Disclaimer on Risk-O-Meter:

Investors are advised before investing to evaluate a scheme not only on the basis of the Product labeling (including the Riskometer) but also on other quantitative and qualitative factors such as performance, portfolio, fund managers, asset manager, etc, and shall also consult their Professional advisors, if they are unsure about the suitability of the scheme before investing.