Active vs Passive ETF: Differences, Benefits, Risks and Returns

Active vs Passive ETF: Differences, Benefits, Risks and Returns

Active vs passive ETF investing differs in strategy: an active ETF selects securities, while a passive ETF tracks an index with measurable tracking error. Explore actively managed ETF vs passive funds on the  Bajaj Broking website based on your investment goals.


Overview
FAQs

Rs. 100- Rs. 10 crore

Start investing with Rs. 100 | Easy KYC | Expert-managed funds

SIP Investing - How to Start, Manage & Optimise Your SIP
 

SIP Investing - How to Start, Manage & Optimise Your SIP

In summary


Active and passive Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) follow different investment strategies. Active ETFs involve investment decisions by fund managers, while passive ETFs aim to track a specified index or benchmark.


  • Active ETFs rely on fund manager decisions.
  • Passive ETFs track a chosen benchmark.
  • Active management may involve higher costs.
  • Passive ETFs face tracking differences.
  • Both ETFs carry market risks.
  • Returns depend on underlying investment performance.

The choice depends on investment goals, expenses, risk tolerance, and product availability. Neither active nor passive management guarantees higher returns or protection against losses.

Show More
Show Less

What is active ETF investing?

Active ETF investing involves a fund manager making investment decisions according to the ETF's stated investment objective. Unlike a passive ETF that seeks to replicate an index, an actively managed ETF allows the manager to select securities, adjust allocations, and respond to market conditions within the fund's investment mandate. The objective may be to outperform a benchmark, manage particular risks, or implement a specified investment strategy. However, active management does not guarantee benchmark outperformance. The fund's returns depend on investment decisions, market movements, portfolio expenses, and trading costs.

Show More
Show Less

What is passive ETF investing?

Passive ETF investing involves purchasing units of a fund that aims to track a specified benchmark or index. Instead of selecting securities to outperform the market, the fund follows an index-based investment strategy.

For example, a Nifty 50 ETF seeks to replicate the performance of the Nifty 50 index by holding securities according to its permitted replication approach.


Passive ETFs can track different investment categories, including:

  • Broad-market equity indices
  • Sectoral and thematic indices
  • Government and corporate bond indices
  • Gold and other eligible commodity benchmarks

Although passive ETFs aim to follow their benchmarks, actual returns can differ because of expenses, cash holdings, transaction costs, and tracking differences.

Show More
Show Less

What are the differences between active and passive ETFs?

The main difference between active and passive ETFs is whether the portfolio is managed through discretionary investment decisions or a benchmark-tracking strategy.

The table below compares their main characteristics.

ParameterActive ETFsPassive ETFs
Investment objectiveFollow an active strategy, sometimes seeking benchmark outperformanceReplicate or track a benchmark
Portfolio decisionsFund manager discretionBenchmark-based allocation
Expense ratioMay be higher due to active managementOften lower due to index tracking
Return driversSecurity selection and market performanceUnderlying index performance
DiversificationDepends on portfolio strategyDepends on benchmark composition
Main risksMarket risk, manager decisions, and portfolio concentrationMarket risk, tracking difference, and concentration
Performance evaluationCompare results with an appropriate benchmarkEvaluate tracking performance against the benchmark
TradingExchange-based, where listedExchange-based

Neither category automatically has a lower risk level.

For example, a passive ETF tracking a narrow sector index can carry more concentration risk than an actively managed ETF holding securities across several sectors.

Show More
Show Less

What are the pros and cons of actively managed ETFs?

Actively managed ETFs allow fund managers to adjust investments based on market conditions and research. While this creates opportunities for benchmark outperformance, it also involves additional costs and investment risks.

 

Advantages of actively managed ETFs

The main advantages of actively managed ETFs include:

  • Active security selection: Fund managers can choose securities based on company fundamentals, valuations, and growth prospects.
  • Portfolio flexibility: Managers can adjust investment allocations according to market conditions and the fund's investment mandate.
  • Potential for higher returns: Successful investment decisions may help an ETF outperform its benchmark, although returns are not guaranteed.
  • Risk management: Managers can review portfolio exposures and make adjustments to manage specific investment risks, without eliminating market losses.

 

Limitations of actively managed ETFs

Active management involves costs and risks that investors should evaluate carefully. The main limitations include:

  • Higher expenses: Actively managed ETFs may have higher expense ratios due to investment research, portfolio management, and trading activities.
  • Fund manager dependence: Performance depends partly on the fund manager's investment decisions, which may not always produce favourable results.
  • Benchmark underperformance: Active ETFs may generate lower returns than their benchmarks despite following professional investment strategies.
  • Concentration risk: Certain strategies may allocate a larger proportion of assets to specific securities or sectors, increasing exposure to market fluctuations.
  • Liquidity and transaction costs: Low trading volumes, bid-ask spreads, and frequent portfolio adjustments can increase investment costs.

Investors should compare an ETF's expense ratio, performance history, liquidity, and portfolio risks before investing. Active management does not guarantee higher returns.

Show More
Show Less

What are the pros and cons of passively managed ETFs?

Passive ETFs aim to track a specified market index or benchmark. They offer a rules-based investment approach, generally with lower management costs, but remain exposed to market fluctuations and tracking differences.

 

Pros of passively managed ETFs

The main advantages of passively managed ETFs include:

  • Lower expenses: Passive ETFs generally have lower expense ratios because they do not require frequent discretionary security selection.
  • Diversification: ETFs tracking broad-market indices provide exposure to multiple securities through a single investment.
  • Transparency: Investors can identify the benchmark being tracked and understand the ETF's investment approach.
  • Simple investment strategy: Passive ETFs follow predefined index rules, reducing dependence on individual fund managers' investment decisions.
  • Market exposure: Investors can access specific market segments, sectors, or asset categories through index-based investments.

However, diversification depends on the underlying index. Sector-specific ETFs may have concentrated portfolios.

 

Cons of passively managed ETFs

The main limitations of passively managed ETFs include:

  • Market risk: Passive ETFs generally decline when their underlying benchmark falls, subject to tracking differences.
  • Tracking error: Returns may differ from the benchmark because of expenses, cash holdings, and portfolio adjustments.
  • Limited flexibility: Fund managers cannot independently remove underperforming securities unless permitted by the index methodology or replication strategy.
  • Liquidity risk: ETFs with low trading volumes may be difficult to buy or sell at favourable prices.
  • Bid-ask spreads: Differences between buying and selling prices can increase transaction costs.
  • Concentration risk: ETFs tracking narrow indices may have significant exposure to a few companies or sectors.

Investors should evaluate the ETF's expense ratio, tracking error, underlying index, and trading liquidity before investing.

Show More
Show Less

What returns can investors expect from active vs passive ETFs?

Active and passive ETF returns depend on different portfolio management approaches.

Active ETFs seek to implement discretionary strategies, while passive ETFs aim to follow their chosen benchmarks.

 

1. Active ETFs

An active ETF's performance depends on the fund manager's investment decisions and the market performance of its underlying securities.

The fund manager can adjust portfolio holdings within the fund's investment mandate.

An active strategy can generate returns above its benchmark, sometimes referred to as positive alpha.

However, unsuccessful decisions, operating expenses, and trading costs can cause the ETF to underperform.

Investors should assess returns after costs over appropriate periods rather than judging a strategy on a short period of outperformance.

 

2. Passive ETFs

Passive ETFs aim to deliver returns close to their underlying benchmarks before considering tracking differences and expenses.

For example, if an index earns 10% during a particular period, its ETF might earn a slightly different return because of fund costs and portfolio implementation.

Passive ETFs can provide exposure to several asset classes, depending on the benchmark.

Tracking error measures the variability of the difference between fund and benchmark returns. Tracking difference measures the actual return gap over a specified period.

Both measures help investors evaluate how closely a passive ETF follows its benchmark.

Show More
Show Less

Conclusion

Choosing between active and passive ETFs depends on the investor's financial goals, risk tolerance, investment horizon, and preference for active or benchmark-based management.

Passive ETFs provide index-linked exposure and often have lower management expenses. Active ETFs use discretionary investment strategies that can outperform or underperform their benchmarks.

Neither approach guarantees positive returns. Investors should review product availability, expenses, diversification, liquidity, and the underlying investment strategy before investing.


Last reviewed: 12 November 2026


Mutual funds are subject to market risk. Please read the scheme-related documents carefully before investing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Choosing between active and passive ETFs

Performance and fund selection

Are active ETFs better?

Active ETFs are not automatically better than passive ETFs. Active management allows fund managers to select securities and adjust portfolios according to their investment strategies. This creates opportunities to outperform benchmarks but also introduces the risk of underperformance. Passive ETFs focus on tracking a benchmark and often have lower management expenses. The appropriate option depends on the underlying investments, costs, risks, and investor objectives. Indian investors should also verify whether the actively managed ETF is available under the applicable regulatory framework.


How to tell if an ETF is active or passive?

A passive ETF will not see a frequent churning of the portfolio and the portfolio disclosures will be more transparent. They are also less expensive than active ETFs and their returns generally align with that of the benchmark index.
 

Can actively managed ETFs beat the market?

Yes, actively managed ETFs can outperform an appropriate market benchmark when their investment decisions are successful. However, benchmark outperformance is not guaranteed. Active managers can make decisions that produce weaker returns, particularly after accounting for investment expenses and transaction costs. Market conditions, portfolio concentration, and investment strategy also influence performance. Investors should compare historical results with a suitable benchmark over matching periods and examine associated risks. Past performance is not indicative of future returns.


What is the best actively managed ETF?

There is no single actively managed ETF that is best for every investor. The appropriate choice depends on the investment strategy, expense ratio, underlying securities, liquidity, risk level, and investment horizon. In India, investors must also distinguish products regulated under the domestic mutual fund framework from actively managed ETFs permitted under international financial services centre regulations. Before comparing specific products, review their current availability, governing regulator, portfolio disclosures, and performance history. High historical returns alone do not establish suitability.


Show More Show Less

Disclaimer

Bajaj Finance Limited ("BFL"), a non-banking financial company registered with the Reserve Bank of India, is registered with the Association of Mutual Funds in India ("AMFI") as a Mutual Fund Distributor under ARN 90319 and distributing the mutual fund as a sub-distributor of Bajaj Financial Securities Limited (BFSL) registered under ARN-163403. BFL does not independently solicit, source, procure, accept or book any new mutual fund business under its own ARN. Any activities undertaken by BFL in relation to mutual fund products shall be limited to the extent permissible under applicable law and the operating arrangement approved for such products. BFL does not act as an investment adviser or research analyst.

BFL does not:

(i)                   provide investment advisory services in any manner or form;

(ii)                 undertake any customised or personalised suitability assessment;

(iii)                conduct independent research or analysis in relation to any mutual fund scheme or other investment; or

(iv)                provide any assurance or guarantee regarding returns, capital protection or performance. Participation in mutual fund products is entirely voluntary.

In addition to displaying the Mutual fund products of Asset Management Companies, some general information is sourced from third parties, is also displayed on As-is basis, which should NOT be construed as any solicitation or attempt to effect transactions in securities or the rendering any investment advice.

Mutual Funds are subject to market risks, including loss of principal amount and Investor should read all Scheme/Offer related documents carefully. The NAV of units issued under the Schemes of mutual funds can go up or down depending on the factors and forces affecting capital markets and may also be affected by changes in the general level of interest rates.

The NAV of the units issued under the scheme may be affected, inter-alia by changes in the interest rates, trading volumes, settlement periods, transfer procedures and performance of individual securities forming part of the Mutual Fund. The NAV will inter-alia be exposed to Price/Interest Rate Risk and Credit Risk. Past performance of any scheme of the Mutual fund do not indicate the future performance of the Schemes of the Mutual Fund.

BFL shall not be responsible or liable for any loss or shortfall incurred by the investors. There may be other/better alternatives to the investment avenues displayed by BFL. Hence, the final investment decision shall at all times exclusively remain with the investor alone and BFL shall not be liable or responsible for any consequences thereof.
Investment by a person residing outside the territorial jurisdiction of India is not acceptable nor permitted.

Disclaimer on Riskometer: The Riskometer is only one indicator of the risk associated with a mutual fund scheme. Before investing, investors should evaluate the scheme with reference to the applicable product labelling and Riskometer as well as other quantitative and qualitative factors, including performance, portfolio composition, fund manager and asset manager. Investors who are uncertain about the suitability of a scheme should consult their professional advisers before investing.

Disclosure: BFL holds AMFI Registration Number 90319. BFL does not independently solicit or book new mutual fund business under its own ARN. Accordingly, references on this platform to mutual fund schemes of Bajaj Finserv Asset Management Limited ("BFSAMC"), a group company of BFL, or of any other Asset Management Company shall not be construed as solicitation, sourcing, procurement, acceptance or booking of new mutual fund business by BFL under ARN 90319. BFL receives commission towards distribution of mutual fund products. BFSAMC is a group company of BFL, carrying business on arm’s length basis without any conflict of interest and in accordance with the prevailing law / regulation.

Disclaimer

Bajaj Finance Limited ("BFL") is an NBFC offering loans, deposits and third-party wealth management products.

The information BFL contained in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute any financial advice. The content herein has been prepared by BFL on the basis of publicly available information, internal sources and other third-party sources believed to be reliable. However, BFL cannot guarantee the accuracy of such information, assure its completeness, or warrant such information will not be changed.

This information should not be relied upon as the sole basis for any investment decisions. Hence, User is advised to independently exercise diligence by verifying complete information, including by consulting independent financial experts, if any, and the investor shall be the sole owner of the decision taken, if any, about suitability of the same.

Disclaimer

Mutual Fund SIP calculator may provide potential investors an approximate estimate on the maturity amount of the monthly SIP, purely based on mathematical calculation of the projected annual return rate selected by investor. However, such calculation does not factor the actual performance by the Asset Management Company (AMC) and should not be treated as any advice or assurance about the actual return of investment. Mutual Funds do not have a fixed rate of return and it is not possible to predict the rate of return.  Please note that the SIP calculator are for illustrations only and do not represent actual returns which may vary depending on various factors including but not limited to actual performance, expense ratio, taxation, exit load (if any), etc.