Open Ended and Closed Ended Funds

Open-ended mutual funds allow you to invest through a lump sum or a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP). You can buy or redeem units at any time, giving you greater flexibility. In contrast, close-ended mutual funds accept investments only during the New Fund Offer (NFO) period. Once the NFO closes, you cannot invest through SIPs or make additional purchases.

Choosing between open-ended and close-ended mutual funds can be challenging for first-time investors. Understanding how each type works and their key differences can help you make an informed decision. This article explains open-ended vs close-ended mutual funds in a simple and clear way.

What are open-ended funds?

Open-ended mutual funds are schemes in which you can buy or sell units on any business day. In these funds, units are purchased and redeemed continuously. They do not have any fixed maturity or lock-in periods. The units are bought or sold directly through the asset management company (AMC) or mutual fund house based on the prevailing net asset value (NAV).

Read more about, What are open ended funds

What are close-ended funds?

Close-ended funds are those schemes whose units are not available for purchase or sale at any time. You can only invest in these schemes during the new fund offer (NFO) period and redeem the investment after the maturity period is complete. Alternatively, you can sell the units of close-ended funds via stock exchanges at the prevailing market price if you want to exit your position and redeem your holdings.

Read more about, What are closed ended funds

Open ended vs Close ended mutual funds - A table comparison

In any close-ended vs open-ended fund comparison, it is crucial to see how the two categories are different from one another. The table below summarises the primary differences between open and close-ended funds.

Open-ended vs closed-ended funds - What investors need to know

Choosing between open-ended and closed-ended mutual funds hinges on understanding their key distinctions. Here's a breakdown to help you navigate:

Investment flexibility:

• Open-ended: Offers continuous buying and selling on business days at the Net Asset Value (NAV). Perfect for dynamic portfolio adjustments.
• Closed-ended: Units are purchased during the initial offering (NFO) and then traded on the stock exchange like stocks. Limited flexibility after the NFO closes.

Investment minimums:

• Open-ended: Often accessible with smaller amounts (Rs. 500 or Rs. 1,000), making them suitable for a wider range of investors.
• Closed-ended: Can sometimes require higher initial lump-sum commitments depending on the fund house, though many now align with lower industry minimums.

Track record evaluation:

• Open-ended: Historical performance data is readily available for informed decision-making.
• Closed-ended: No track record exists before the IPO, requiring a different approach to assessing potential.

Investment strategies:

• Open-ended: Well-suited for long-term investing due to liquidity and the ability to rupee-cost average through SIPs (investing fixed amounts at regular intervals).
• Closed-ended: May employ specific strategies like leverage or focus on particular asset classes, appealing to investors with a high-risk tolerance seeking unique opportunities.

Risk and liquidity:

• Open-ended: Offers liquidity, allowing investors to exit during market dips. This flexibility can be crucial for risk-averse individuals.
• Closed-ended: Often comes with lock-in periods, restricting access to invested funds. This can be advantageous for long-term investors as it allows fund managers to focus on their strategy without short-term pressures.

Tax benefits:

• Open-ended funds: Tax depends on the type of fund (equity or debt) and the holding period. Equity funds may qualify for lower long-term capital gains tax if held for the required period. ELSS funds, which are open-ended, also offer tax deductions of up to Rs. 1.5 lakh under Section 80C, subject to prevailing tax laws.
• Closed-ended funds: Tax treatment is also based on the fund type and holding period. Most closed-ended funds do not provide Section 80C tax benefits unless they are specifically eligible tax-saving schemes. Capital gains tax rules apply when units are redeemed or sold, as per applicable regulations.

Advantages of open-ended funds

Open-ended funds offer various benefits to investors. By choosing these types of funds, you get the following advantages.

• They are highly liquid.
• You can purchase or redeem them at the prevailing NAV.
• You can study the historical performance of such funds before investing in them.
• You can invest in open-ended funds via SIPs for added benefits.
• You can diversify your portfolio with these funds.

Disadvantages of open-ended funds

Before you choose open-ended funds, you must also be mindful of its limitations, which include the following aspects.

• The high level of diversification may increase the market risk.
• You are exposed to the risk of timing your entry into and exit from the markets.
• Poor management could dilute the value of investments.

Advantages of close-ended funds

Close-ended funds also offer unique advantages to investors, some of which are outlined below.

• The fixed capital ensures stability and reduces the cash drag on investments.
• You can trade these funds on exchanges in the secondary market.
• These funds may be comparatively less volatile than open-ended funds.
• They are ideal for medium-term to long-term investments.
• They allow you to spend more time invested in the market rather than timing the market.

Disadvantages of close-ended funds

On the downside, close-ended funds have some risks or limitations that you need to know about before you invest.

• Liquidity may be quite limited for these funds.
• The lock-in period may not align with your end financial goals.
• You cannot start a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) in these funds; you need to invest a lump sum amount.

Which one should you choose?

Now that you know the differences between open and close-ended funds as well as their pros and cons, you can make a more informed choice between the two types of mutual fund schemes. Broadly, here are some guidelines to help you choose:

Open-ended funds are suitable for you if:

• You prioritise liquidity.
• You want the convenience of redeeming your investments based on the current NAV.
• You want the flexibility to adjust your portfolio according to market movements.
• You are interested in SIPs and/or SWPs

Close-ended funds may be suitable for you if:

• You want to invest for a fixed period.
• You do not want immediate liquidity.
• You have a medium-term or long-term outlook.
• You are comfortable with fixed-term and stable investments.

Conclusion

Both open-ended and close-ended funds have their advantages. To make an informed decision, compare open-ended vs close-ended mutual funds, assess the risk-reward ratio, and choose the scheme that best aligns with your financial goals and risk appetite.

Calculate your expected investment returns with the help of our investment calculators