Flat Yield Curve

In the financial domain, some situations occur due to the rise and fall of asset and security values. In finance and economics, these situations are shown using lines on a chart, or bars on a graph, for instance. Lines on a chart may be curved, straight, or going in any direction that best depicts a specific situation. The flat yield curve is a depiction of a situation that arises when there is a limited spread between short-term rates and long-term rates. The flat yield curve is a kind of yield curve that is related to the investment of bonds (typically of the same quality as treasury bonds). For investors, learning about the flat yield curve is an important aspect of investing and you can read on to know about it.

What is the flat yield curve?

The flat yield curve occurs in a situation in which there is only a slight difference between short-term rates and long-term rates related to bonds of identical credit qualities. This curve is reflected by a diagram, a table of numbers, or a graph that displays bond yields that pose identical credit risks but differ in their maturities.

The flat yield curve defines the connection between the yield on short-term bonds and long-term bonds. As an investor or a stock market player, you may find it interesting to learn about the flat yield curve as it helps you to grasp the bond markets better. Additionally, if you are investing in low-risk mutual fund schemes that invest in bonds, then this concept may be useful.

Understanding the meaning of the flat yield curve with an example

If you want the answer to the question, “What is a flat yield curve?”, you may need an example to grasp the concept better. Before that, let us delve a little into bond yields. A bond yield is a return on investment from a bond that is held by investors. In other words, a bond yield is the rate of interest that an investor may earn on their bond investment. Bonds are either short-term, medium-term, or long-term, depending on their maturity periods. When the yields of short-term bonds and long-term bonds are the same, a situation occurs wherein there is little or no difference in the investment return for short-term and long-term bonds. This is visually shown by a flat curve - the flat yield curve.

As an example of a flat yield curve, you could take the case of government bonds which may be held for different maturity periods, but yield the same or similar returns. So, an investor may come across a 2-year bond that generates yields at an interest rate of 5% and a 30-year bond that gives a 5.1% return. Here, both types of bonds give the same yield (as interest rates are almost the same), but their maturity periods are different. The 30-year bond is a long-term bond, and the 2-year bond is a short-term bond.

Furthermore, as an investor, you may think that the 2-year bond has a lower risk level (as it is held for a shorter period) relative to the 30-year bond (as it is held for a long period). As you can see, the flat yield curve can be useful when you choose to invest in debt instruments like bonds, or in debt-based mutual funds that you may find on the Bajaj Finserv Mutual Fund Platform.

Uses of the flat yield curve

The flat yield curve is an easy concept to understand and investors should know about it when they seek investment opportunities in debt instruments like bonds. In general, interest rates are high when capital is lent for long periods (as lenders do not receive any money during long timeframes). On the other hand, short-term loans have less interest. Additionally, a flat yield curve indicates that lenders with money to lend are prepared to receive the same interest rate for short-term and long-term loans.

From a historical point of view, the flat yield curve and recession are linked. A flat yield curve translates to the fact that lenders may be concerned about their money having less opportunity of earning interest in the future, and decide to lend in the present so that they can secure a high interest rate for a longer duration. When fewer people want to borrow money, that means there is reduced economic activity and less demand. This implies a potential recession in the future.

When a flat yield curve is seen, investors become wary of new investments, and this may not be a time for any stock investment or investing in mutual funds. The curve may signify uncertainty in the stock market, preventing investors from taking the “long” view on investment. Essentially, the flat yield curve shows a potential for upcoming inflation and recession and lenders may be worried about loaning large amounts of money at this time.

Examples of flat yield curve

The flat yield curve meaning can be better understood with some realistic examples. Consider the two examples below:

Example 1

Anil is an investor who wishes to earn interest by lending money through a bond. Nonetheless, lately, the economy has displayed strength and the country’s central bank has increased short-term interest rates. The result is the flat yield curve. The implication of this is a potential recession. There are some investment options for an investor in this situation. Anil may divide his capital and invest half of it in a bond and the other half in other investment instruments. Of course, Anil will have to select the bond to be invested in as lock-in periods must be considered while investing in long-term bonds.

Example 2

This example deals with the economy of the USA. US 10-year Treasury bonds experienced a 16-year high and then fell sharply. This resulted in a flat yield curve. This occurred as investors put a hold on selling bonds to fully grasp interest rates and act in accordance. When this took place, besides the 10-year bonds, bonds with different maturity periods also experienced a flat yield curve. Nonetheless, such a flattening of the yield curve is not a long-term event. This would only be a temporary situation as the US market, the largest global economy, will show signs of recovery. Thus, the flat yield curve will likely show an improvement sooner than later.

Implications of the flat yield curve

You may have an answer to the question, “What is a flat yield curve?”, but this is not all you need to know about this concept. You must also learn about the implications of a situation in which the flat yield curve shows itself. You have already learned that the flat yield curve indicates the spread that occurs between the yields of short-term and long-term bonds. This can affect the investments and decisions of those who hold bonds and those who wish to invest in bonds. Here are the key implications of the flat yield curve:

• There may be a reduction in the investment of long-term bonds as investors believe they will not benefit from bonds held for long durations. As they find that short-term bonds give them the same returns, they may choose to invest for short periods with the same interest rates. Therefore, there will be a surge in the demand for short-term bond investment, as it poses less of a risk due to a brief tenure.

• When the yield curve turns flat, it tells investors that the government or central bank may be planning to raise interest rates. This may be done to control and manage inflation. Rising interest rates indicate that the difference between the short-term bond yield and the long-term bond yield will rise. This will turn the flat yield curve into a sharp or steep curve.

• The flat yield curve serves as a reliable indicator if you are an investor who wishes to compare mutual funds or make plans to invest in the markets in general. In times of a flat yield curve, investors may not put their faith in the market. They tend to feel that markets won’t perform optimally and investments may fail to give adequate returns. This may lead to low investment activity and low liquidity in the general economy.

Reasons for flat yield curves

As the gap between short-term bond yields and long-term bond yields narrows, the flat yield curve takes shape. There are several reasons for this occurrence, and the situations that have historically given rise to a flat yield curve are explained below (based on the US economy’s aspects):

1. The Fed’s monetary policy

The US Federal Reserve may cause a flat yield curve due to its artificial rise in short-term interest rates.

The US Federal Reserve (the Fed) promotes stability in prices, maximum employment, and moderate interest rates for the long term by executing monetary policies as required. If the Fed raises bond coupon rates, it will be long before the new rates are reflected in the yield curve. This is because the Fed has greater influence on the left of the curve than on the right. However, the right side is more difficult to manage.

What you should understand here is that the rates of bonds that are outstanding (yet to mature) will not change with the new rate as they have to reach maturity. Therefore, the Fed’s short-term rate hike tends to result in a flat yield curve as it lifts the left side of the curve.

2. Potential recession on the horizon

There are two sides to the bond yield equation - the price of the bond and the coupon payment of the bond based on the Fed’s rate of interest. In case people start investing in more long-term bonds, bond prices will rise (on the right side of the yield curve). If the prices of long-term bonds increase, their yields tend to decrease. This caused a flattening of the yield curve. This may not indicate a positive outcome as it means that people have invested in long-term bonds to a degree where the yield is not appealing compared to short-term bond yield. Simply put, investors may believe that there is a broad risk that overrides the risk of long-term bond investment. Regardless of what the actions of investors are, the thought behind them is that a slowdown of the economy is predicted.

3. Lower inflation ahead

In case investors anticipate a decrease in inflation at some point in the future, the yield curve may flatten. Typically, people invest in long-term bonds as they expect high yields to hedge against inflation. This way, their long-term investments are safeguarded from the adverse effects of inflation. Now, if they expect a fall in inflation, they may not be as worried about the effect of inflation on long-term investments. Therefore, as they see no need to protect long-term investments from inflation, they may invest in short-term bonds as they can earn the same returns and avoid their capital being tied up for long durations and lock-in periods. This is what causes a flat yield curve.

The flat yield curve - An indicator for lenders

The flat yield curve is not an indicator that is cast in stone and should be depended on for investment decision-making completely. While it can be considered to estimate the future of the economy, it is important to note that it could appear at any time, and no one can predict when it will occur. Furthermore, the flat yield curve could remain flat for a short duration, maybe just a few weeks, and then become normal. Additionally, people should refrain from predicting future events based on the past.

If, after learning about the flat yield curve meaning, investors still cannot avoid being in a recession, what can they do to prepare themselves? Investors may consider diversifying their financial portfolios and establishing emergency funds. Additionally, investors should consider their risk appetite before choosing their investments.

All in all, if investors possess high-quality portfolios, they do not have to be concerned about impending economic downturns.

Key takeaways

• A flat yield curve occurs when there are no interest rate differences between those of long-term bonds and short-term bonds. This makes long-term bonds less attractive to investors who then start investing in short-term bonds.

• When the yield curve becomes flat, it potentially indicates that market players and investors have lost faith in the market’s growth prospects. This is because investors see signals of uncertainty and transition during such times.

• A flat yield curve may indicate an upcoming recession, prompting investors to invest less of their capital. Based on historical information, a flat yield curve tends to be a precursor for an inverted yield curve which is a more definite sign of a future recession.

• Investors can respond to a flat yield curve by using the Barbell strategy which involves balancing a financial portfolio with short-term bonds and long-term bonds.

Conclusion

A flat yield curve arises when there is no difference between the interest rates of short-term bonds and those of long-term bonds. When a situation such as this occurs, investors may turn away from long-term bond investment and invest in short-term bonds. Typically, the high rates of interest that long-term bonds offer no longer appear attractive when interest rates of most types of bonds tend to be identical. In the broader scheme of things, a flat yield curve may signal an impending recession and investors may do well to diversify their portfolios to combat such a situation.

Investment may not be child’s play, but it is easy if you do some due diligent research and aim to diversify your financial portfolio to hedge against risk. You can start with mutual fund investment on the Bajaj Finserv Mutual Fund Platform, where you can get onto the investment bandwagon seamlessly. You get to choose from 1000-plus mutual funds, based on your unique financial aims and risk profile, and can easily sign up for a mutual fund of your preference. With efficient tools to calculate potential returns, calculators help you make realistic investment choices to help you to realise your investment dreams.

Essential tools for all mutual fund investors

Mutual Fund Calculator	Lumpsum Calculator	Systematic Investment Plan Calculator	Step Up SIP Calculator
SBI SIP Calculator	HDFC SIP Calculator	Nippon India SIP Calculator	ABSL SIP Calculator