Difference between collision and comprehensive insurance

A comprehensive guide on understanding what collision and comprehensive insurance policies are and their differences.
Get Quote
Difference between collision and comprehensive insurance
Get Quote
3 mins
Sep 15, 2026

Car insurance is an important investment that keeps you financially secure to tackle expenses related to damage or mishap involving your car. It provides financial coverage against damage or loss caused by unforeseen accidents, theft, or other covered events. While looking to buy a car insurance policy, it is important to know the different types of insurance policies available. Collision and comprehensive insurance are two types of motor insurance policies. Though both types secure a car, their coverage differs significantly. Collision insurance is more popular in abroad, and still very new to India.

Understanding the difference between collision and comprehensive insurance is crucial to determine which coverage is best for your car.


What is collision insurance?


Collision insurance is a type of car insurance. It covers the cost of repairing or replacing your car if damaged in a collision with another vehicle, object, or has rolled over. It is not necessarily required under the law, but it is mandatory if the car has been financed through a loan or lease.

Collision insurance covers damage to your vehicle regardless of fault in the accident. If there is a collision, your insurance company will cover all repair costs up to the policy limit minus your deductible. For instance, suppose a car is damaged due to an accident, the repair cost comes up to Rs. 50,000, and you have a deductible of Rs. 10,000. The insurance company will pay Rs. 40,000.


What is comprehensive insurance?


Comprehensive insurance, also known as 'other than collision,' is a type of insurance coverage that covers damages caused from accidents, natural calamities, and man-made activities. It is an optional coverage and also covers theft, vandalism, fire, floods, or falling objects.

Comprehensive car insurance also compensates for the car damages up to the policy limit minus your deductible.


When to file a comprehensive vs. collision claim


Choose the claim type based on how the vehicle was damaged. Comprehensive claims generally apply to non-collision incidents, while collision claims cover damage caused by an accident involving another vehicle or object.


  • File a comprehensive claim: For theft, vandalism, fire, natural disasters, falling objects or animal-related damage.
  • File a collision claim: For damage caused by hitting another vehicle, pole, tree or other object.
  • Check the deductible: Consider the repair cost, deductible and policy terms before filing a claim.

Things to consider when buying car insurance with collision coverage


FactorWhat to consider
Coverage scopeCheck whether the policy covers collision-related vehicle damage and understand applicable exclusions.
DeductibleCompare the deductible amount with the premium and your ability to pay during a claim.
Insured Declared Value (IDV)Choose an appropriate IDV based on your car’s current market value.
PremiumCompare premiums from different insurers while considering the coverage and benefits offered.
Add-onsEvaluate useful add-ons, such as zero depreciation, roadside assistance or engine protection, based on your needs.
Claim processCheck the insurer’s claim procedure, required documents and network garage availability.

Difference between collision and comprehensive insurance

CategoryComprehensive InsuranceCollision Insurance
Perils coveredCovers non-collision events such as theft, fire, natural disasters, vandalism and damage caused by falling objects.Covers damage to the insured car resulting from a collision with another vehicle or an object.
Liability coverageGenerally does not cover third-party liability arising from an accident.Generally does not cover third-party liability arising from an accident.
RequirementUsually optional, depending on the policy and applicable requirements.Usually optional and may be chosen based on the car’s value and the policyholder’s needs.
Coverage scopeProtects against specified non-collision risks that can damage or result in the loss of the vehicle.Focuses on repairing or compensating for damage to the insured vehicle following a covered collision.
AvailabilityAvailable as part of eligible motor insurance policies or as selected coverage, subject to policy terms.Available under eligible motor insurance policies, subject to the insurer’s terms, conditions and coverage options.

Difference between collision and comprehensive insurance

Comprehensive and collision insurance differ mainly in the types of vehicle damage they cover. The comparison below highlights their key differences.

CategoryComprehensive InsuranceCollision Insurance
Perils coveredCovers losses from theft, fire, natural disasters, riots, and other non-collision events, subject to policy terms.Covers damage caused when your car collides with another vehicle or an object.
Liability coverageDoes not cover third-party liability. It focuses on damage or loss to the insured vehicle.Does not cover third-party liability. It covers damage to your own vehicle after a covered collision.
RequirementUsually optional, but may be required by a lender for a financed vehicle.Usually optional, but lenders may require it for financed vehicles.
Coverage scopeCovers a wider range of non-collision risks affecting the insured vehicle.Specifically covers collision-related damage to the insured vehicle.
AvailabilityAvailable as an optional own-damage component with eligible car insurance policies.Available as an optional coverage component, depending on the insurer and policy structure.

The exact coverage, exclusions, deductibles, and availability depend on the insurer and policy terms. Review the policy wording before purchase.



Do I need both collision and comprehensive coverage?

Collision insurance is more popular in the USA, and not sold in India. In India, you get two types of motor insurance – comprehensive and third-party insurance.

In India, it is mandatory for every vehicle owner to have a third-party insurance as per Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. Buy a comprehensive insurance is optional. However, it depends on your individual circumstances and needs.


Things to Consider When Buying Car Insurance with Collision Coverage

Consider the following factors before buying car insurance with collision coverage:

Things to ConsiderWhat to Check
Coverage needsAssess your car’s value and collision-related risks.
Policy typeCheck whether collision coverage is included under own-damage or comprehensive insurance.
IDVSelect an appropriate Insured Declared Value for potential claim payouts.
DeductiblesCompare deductibles and understand your share of claim expenses.
Inclusions and exclusionsReview covered collision events, exclusions, and applicable conditions.
PremiumCompare premiums and coverage benefits across available policies before purchasing.

Review the policy wording carefully to understand the applicable coverage, exclusions, deductibles, and claim conditions.


 


When to File a Comprehensive vs. Collision Claim

The type of damage determines whether you should file a comprehensive or collision claim. Comprehensive  insurance generally covers non-collision events, while collision insurance covers damage caused by an accident involving your car and another vehicle or object.

  • File a comprehensive claim: Use this coverage for theft, fire, vandalism, natural disasters, falling objects, or animal-related damage.
  • File a collision claim: Use this coverage when your car hits another vehicle, pole, tree, fence, or other object.
  • Check your policy: Review deductibles, exclusions, and claim conditions before filing.


Explore More Under Motor Insurance 
Third Party Insurance IDV CalculatorCheck car Insurance 
Car Companies in IndiaMotor Insurance Electric Car Insurance

Related videos

Disclaimer

*T&C Apply. Bajaj Finance Limited (‘BFL’) is a registered corporate agent of third party insurance products of Bajaj Life Insurance Limited (Formerly known as Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company Limited), HDFC Life Insurance Company Limited, Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC), Axis Max Life Insurance Limited (formerly known as Max Life Insurance Company Limited.),  Bajaj General Insurance Limited(Formerly known as Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company Limited), SBI General Insurance Company Limited, ACKO General Insurance Company Limited, HDFC ERGO General Insurance Company, TATA AIG General Insurance Company Limited, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Limited, New India Assurance Limited, Chola MS General Insurance Company Limited, Zurich Kotak General Insurance Company Limited, Star Health & Allied Insurance Company Limited, Care Health Insurance Company Limited, Niva Bupa Health Insurance Company Limited, Aditya Birla Health Insurance Company Limited and Manipal Cigna Health Insurance Company Limited under the IRDAI composite registration number CA0101. Please note that, BFL does not underwrite the risk or act as an insurer. Your purchase of an insurance product is purely on a voluntary basis after your exercise of an independent due diligence on the suitability, viability of any insurance product. Any decision to purchase insurance product is solely at your own risk and responsibility and BFL shall not be liable for any loss or damage that any person may suffer, whether directly or indirectly. For more details on risk factors, terms and conditions and exclusions please read the product sales brochure & policy wordings carefully before concluding a sale. Tax benefits applicable if any, will be as per the prevailing tax laws. Tax laws are subject to change. BFL does NOT provide Tax/Investment advisory services. Please consult your advisors before proceeding to purchase an insurance product. Visitors are hereby informed that their information submitted on the website may also be shared with insurers. BFL is also distributor of other third party products from Assistance service providers such as CPP Assistance Services Private Limited, Bajaj Finance Health Limited. etc. All product information such as premium, benefits, exclusions, value added services etc. are authentic and solely based on the information received from the respective Insurance company or the respective Assistance provider company.

Note- While we have made all the efforts and taken utmost care in gathering precise information about the products, features, benefits etc. However, BFL cannot be held liable for any direct or indirect damage/loss. We request our customers to conduct their research about these products and refer to the respective products sales brochure and policy/membership wordings before concluding sales.